What can I say? I'm addicted to Jelly Bellys, and if you're here, I'm not alone. But it's impossible to easily find recipes on the Net--the Jelly Belly home page doesn't give more than two or three of the same ones! So here's my solution: recipes picked up from different bags and different people's suggestions.
NOTICE: As of 9 March 2008, I am no longer taking recipes by e-mail. I have this MASSIVE BACKLOG of recipes in my inbox, and I am still recovering from a December hard drive crash. The site was backed up, but... reconstructing everything and surviving full-time work and part-time grad school has put this at the bottom of the list. I plan to go through said backlog and update this site - AFTER the semester ends in May. But yeah, no more submissions.
The Jelly Belly Menu is still up, but I have stopped updating it - it's not up-to-date, and since this page started, Jelly Belly has put up a graphic menu of its 50 official flavors and more. The only reason it's still up is because of the comparisons at the bottom.
Some people occasionally send me recipes that include flavors that I've never seen and that don't appear in the Jelly Belly Official Flavors Guide. I've usually put the recipes up anyway, but with a suggested possible alternate flavor name in parentheses next to it. Some just have a (?) when I've never seen the flavor before and can't figure out an equivalent - even when I factor in the Bertie Botts beans.
*denotes flavors that are not in the Official Flavor Guide, but that can be found in the online Jelly Belly shop on the official site.
| Name | Recipe | Sent In By |
| Banana Split | 2 Chocolate Pudding + 2 Cotton Candy + 2 Top Banana + 2 Very Cherry | Existing Menu |
| Macaroon | 2 Coconut + 1 Very Cherry | |
| PB&J Sandwich | 2 Peanut Butter + 2 Grape Jelly | |
| Chocolate Covered Cherry | 1 Chocolate Pudding + 1 Very Cherry | |
| Strawberry Milkshake | 2 Strawberry Daiquiri + 1 A&W Cream Soda | |
| Candy Apple | 2 Green Apple + 1 Cinnamon | |
| Cinnamon Popcorn Balls | 2 Buttered Popcorn + 1 Sizzling Cinnamon | |
| Peaches and Cream | 1 Peach + 1 A&W Cream Soda | |
| Poached Pear in Raspberry Sauce | 1 Juicy Pear + 1 Raspberry | |
| Cafe Mocha | 2 Cappuccino + 1 Chocolate Pudding + 1 A&W Cream Soda | |
| Lemon Meringue Pie | 2 Lemon + 2 Coconut | |
| Chocolate Dipped Strawberry | 2 Strawberry Daiquiri + 1 Chocolate Pudding | |
| Blue Raspberry | 2 Blueberry + 2 Raspberry | |
| Mint Chocolate | 3 Chocolate Pudding + 2 Peppermint Stick | |
| Movie Theater Floor | 1 Bubble Gum + 1 Buttered Popcorn + 1 Root Beer | David Stovall |
| Pink Lemonade | 1 Cotton Candy + 1 Lemon | Consuelo z |
| Chocolate Dipped Banana | 1 Top Banana + 1 Chocolate Pudding | |
| Peanut Butter and Banana Sandwich | 2 Top Banana + 2 Peanut Butter | |
| S'mores | 1 Caramel Corn + 2 Marshmallow + 1 Chocolate Pudding | |
| Honeydew Melon | 1 Cantaloupe + 1 Green Apple | |
| Root Beer Float | 2 Root Beer + 1 Cream Soda | |
| Jalapeno Poppers | 1 Buttered Popcorn + 1 Jalapeno | |
| Strawberry-Kiwi Refresher | 1 Kiwi + 1 Strawberry Daiquiri | |
| Banana Cream Pie | 1 Top Banana + 1 Cream Soda + 1 Coconut | Brian |
| Orange Dream Bar | 2 Orange Sherbet + 1 Cream Soda | |
| Berry Smoothie | 1 Strawberry Daiquiri + 1 Blueberry + 1 Raspberry | |
| Mud Pie | 2 Chocolate Pudding + 1 Cappuccino + 1 Peanut Butter | |
| Pineapple Salsa | 2 Crushed Pineapple + 1 Jalapeno | |
| Rainbow Sherbet | 1 Blueberry + 1 Watermelon + 1 Lemon-lime + 1 Raspberry + 1 Strawberry Cheesecake | Alexandria and Crystal |
| Tutti-Frutti Soda | 1 Top Banana + 1 Cream Soda + 1 Coconut | |
| Peachberry Bubble | 2 Tutti Frutti + 2 Peach | Alisha |
| Blueberry Muffin | 2 Blueberry + 1 Buttered Popcorn | Michael |
| Bottom of Your Shoe | 3 Bubble Gum + 1 Licorice + 1 Cinnamon + 1 Peanut Butter | Andrew and David |
| Twizzlers | 3 Hawaiian Punch + 1 Licorice | |
| Mellow Yellow | 2 Lemon Lime + 1 Lemon | |
| Orange Peach Juice | 2 Orange Juice + 2 Peach | |
| Sweet Fried Banana | 1 Top Banana + 1 Cinnamon + 1 Buttered Popcorn | Dan |
| Fruit Salad | 1 Cantaloupe + 1 Crushed Pineapple + 1 Green Apple + 1 Pink Grapefruit + 1 Tangerine | |
| Tropical Fruit Salad | 1 Cantaloupe + 1 Coconut + 2 Crushed Pineapple + 1 Hawaiian Punch + 1 Peach + 1 Pink Grapefruit + 1 Very Cherry | Sylina |
| "Primary Colour It's Just Fruity In My Mouth" Flavour | 1 Blueberry + 1 Lemon + 1 Cherry | Sarah C. |
| Yukky Pie | 1 Top Banana + 1 Cinnamon + 1 Buttered Popcorn + 2 Orange Juice + 2 Peach | Sam |
| French Vanilla Coffee | 1 French Vanilla + 1 Cappuccino | No name given |
| Candy Apple | 2 Red Apple + 1 Caramel Apple | Andrew M. |
| Tropical Punch | 1 Pina Colada + 1 Crushed Pineapple + 1 Coconut + 1 Hawaiian Punch | No name given |
| Starbucks Mocha Valencia | 2 Expresso (Cafe Latte?) + 1-2 Orange Juice | Tim, Jen, and Jacob F. |
| Rocky Road | 1 French Vanilla + 1 Chocolate Pudding + 1 Peanut Butter | No name given |
| Toasted Caramel Corn | 1 Toasted Marshmallow + 1 Caramel Corn | Ryan B. |
| Sizzlin' Watermelon | 1 Sizzling Cinnamon + 1 Watermelon | |
| Sizzlin' Caramel Watermelon French Banana Split | 1 Top Banana + 1 Chocolate Pudding + 1 Crushed Pineapple + 1 Strawberry Jam + 1 Very Cherry + 1 A&W Cream Soda + 1 Caramel Corn + 1 Watermelon + 1 French Banana + 1 Sizzlin' Cinnamon | |
| Mr. Clean | 1 Juicy Pear + 1 Lemon Lime | Joe T. |
| Cinnamon Bubble Gum | 2 Cinnamon + 2 Bubble Gum | No name given |
| Berry Smoothie | 1 Strawberry Daiquiri + 1 Blueberry + 1 Raspberry | Lily C. |
| Happy Hour | 1 Pina Colada + 1 Margarita + 1 Strawberry Daiquiri | Mara T. |
| Scrumptious Surprise | 1 Peanut Butter + 1 Coconut + 1 Very Cherry + 1 Licorice | Rachel, Gerry, and Katie |
| Hot Wings | 2 Roasted Garlic* + 1 Tabasco* + 1 Jalapeno | No name given |
| Kiwi Cheesecake | 2 Kiwi + 1 Strawberry Cheesecake | Brittany, Lindsay and Rachael |
| Chocolate Mocha | 2 Chocolate Pudding + 1 Cappuccino | No name given |
| Hot Chocolate | 1 Toasted Marshmallow + 1 Chocolate Pudding | Michael St. Clair |
| French Sizzling Berry | 1 Berry Blue + 1 French Vanilla + 1 Sizzling Cinnamon | Josh T. |
| Breakfast | 2 Espresso + 1 Buttered Toast* + 1 Orange Juice | No name given |